FC Bayern Forum

He's been great most games. Let's not be unfair.

Well he struck me as not being in top form lately... Not being unfair, just pointing it out... At 22 he’s still got a good way to go and enough time to do so...

I was suspicious to begin with but the games before this he’s been one of our better defenders. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

He has been decent lately, he is not capable to command a defense yet let alone Bayern's but it's ok, we're giving free pass to Boateng for years making these mistakes consistently, it's a good thing that Sule tries,fails,recovers and goes for it again same with Kimmich(CB) when he came, that's the process of learning and developing.

I like the guy,he has character and will, I strongly believe that he'll develop into a great Bayern player next to Boammels
He was terrible yesterday but it's ok, it was game that didn't hurt us much and IMO most of the players were bad while at the same time under these circumstances(injuries,no attackers,players out of position) you can't ask much but take it as it comes.

Go on Niklas, you got it big fella!

Still how can he claim it’s not a penalty

#12 wrote:Still how can he claim it’s not a penalty

It's a penalty, but a harsh one...ball seemed to graze his fingertips, I've seen penalty calls denied for a whole lot more than that. I think that was his main frustration/point.

It was a deliberate handball IMO. He moved slightly his hand to prevent the ball from passing.

ramsej84 wrote:

Roonzil wrote:The hate he's getting online for today's handball is unreal....Jesus, he's 22 and playing pretty well for a top team. Today wasn't his best game, but it's not like the other defenders were playing 10/10 performances.

Really? That is very sad and childish...

True, but you are usually one of those hot headed emotional fans

I'm really mad on him It's the second time that he loses his mind and causes a silly penalty. I know this time, the decision was almost 50-50, but as a central defender you can't have your hand in the penalty area as he did in Gladbach, and you can't be so stupid in your movements and tackling the ball as he did today in Stuttgard. And don't make him excuses, he is not a 18-19 years defender. He has a couple of seasons in the Bundesliga, you can't miss the ball like he did today. Not for a Bayern defender. If he makes every season 4-5 stupid mistakes like he did today, than we will have big problems. He is a monster of muscles and very tall, but I'm starting to regret that we did not went after Jonathan Tah. Sule is very slow, but very slow, and what is more important, he does not compensate this by beeing very smart and clever when he is positioning himself againts the attacking opponents, and even less when he goes for the ball in neck-and-neck situations. He will never, be a Boateng or Hummels heirs. He does not have the technique, movements, and intelligence. All in all he will never be a world class defender. I still don't understant why we went for him, he is too slow, even for his centimenters.

Mircea_1984 wrote:I'm really mad on him It's the second time that he loses his mind and causes a silly penalty. I know this time, the decision was almost 50-50, but as a central defender you can't have your hand in the penalty area as he did in Gladbach, and you can't be so stupid in your movements and tackling the ball as he did today in Stuttgard. And don't make him excuses, he is not a 18-19 years defender. He has a couple of seasons in the Bundesliga, you can't miss the ball like he did today. Not for a Bayern defender. If he makes every season 4-5 stupid mistakes like he did today, than we will have big problems. He is a monster of muscles and very tall, but I'm starting to regret that we did not went after Jonathan Tah. Sule is very slow, but very slow, and what is more important, he does not compensate this by beeing very smart and clever when he is positioning himself againts the attacking opponents, and even less when he goes for the ball in neck-and-neck situations. He will never, be a Boateng or Hummels heirs. He does not have the technique, movements, and intelligence. All in all he will never be a world class defender. I still don't understant why we went for him, he is too slow, even for his centimenters.

I thought that he is pretty fast considering his height/weight.

22 years old "he will never be.."

Should I put that Boa handball at the Euros here as well, or nah? Or what about Boa vs Hoffenheim 2015 Hinrunde?

Don't act like other defenders don't make similar mistakes, or act like players stop developing after they hit 20.

Yes, Süle made another avoidable mistake, but I doubt every referee would've given the penalty.


Verzonden vanaf mijn iPhone met Tapatalk

You sure?
I mean the ref today didn’t but he didn’t see it... It was the VAR...

#12 wrote:You sure?
I mean the ref today didn’t but he didn’t see it... It was the VAR...

VAR isn't be all end all imo Still a human decision, weighing rules and circumstances.


Verzonden vanaf mijn iPhone met Tapatalk