FC Bayern Forum

[ramsej84]

Ribbeck was nothing special either... the worst German coach ever.

[runaway]

Joachim Loew’s Germany Squad Take Tube To Wembley For Training Session [source]

And here’s a disgruntled Jogi Loew claiming Thomas Muller back at the ‘Lost and Found’ kiosk after the Bayern forward wandered off in the search of some pick’n'mix and got lost…

[FCBayernMunchen]

Congratulations to the female U-17 team, who are the new European Champions, beating Spain on penalties in the final.

[MUTU]

Congratulations to the female U-17 team, who are the new European Champions, beating Spain on penalties in the final.

Cool Seems like the young women have more 'balls' than the ones in the senior men's national team as they beat Italy in a semifinal and they won a final against Spain

[DerKaiser]

Here you guys can vote for the best german national player of 2013... I went with Lahm

http://fanclub.dfb.de/index.php?id=1009

[Tedesco]

Jup. No question about Lahm.

Shame Özil is ahead.

[MUTU]

Voted for Lahm as well.

[MUTU]

The Bundesliga top scorer, 28-year old Raffael, who has nine goals and five assists so far said he would play for Germany if Joachim Löw wanted him. [source]

It's true that Germany's options up front are on the thin side, but I seriously doubt they would do this. They're too proud for that. And national teams are not clubs anyway...

Bild's photo-editing showing Raffael in a Germany shirt:

[scaPEPgoat]

The Bundesliga top scorer, 28-year old Raffael, who has nine goals and five assists so far said he would play for Germany if Joachim Löw wanted him. [source]

It's true that Germany's options up front are on the thin side, but I seriously doubt they would do this. They're too proud for that. And national teams are not clubs anyway...

Bild's photo-editing showing Raffael in a Germany shirt:

How too proud? What about Cacau? They played him over real Germans on 23 occasions.

[MUTU]

Different. Cacau learned all of his professional football in Germany. He got his citizenship after having lived in Germany for over 8 years, just like any normal person could. He learned football the German way.

On the other hand Raffael has been in Germany since 2008. He learned football elsewhere before that. He is 28 years old.

It is a subtle difference, but I think it matters a bit.

[FCB general]

Wow... So he should get an opportunity more than natives as Max Kruse, Volland, Herrmann, even Podolski... Yeah, right...

p.s. He still hasn't lived in Germany for 8 years to request citizenship unlike Cacau who did and still is.

[scaPEPgoat]

Different. Cacau learned all of his professional football in Germany. He got his citizenship after having lived in Germany for over 8 years, just like any normal person could. He learned football the German way.

On the other hand Raffael has been in Germany since 2008. He learned football elsewhere before that. He is 28 years old.

It is a subtle difference, but I think it matters a bit.

No way. Cacau was born in 1981 and did not play for his first German team until 2000. Hardly learned his football in Germany. he got his citizenship in Feb 2009 and made his international debut 3 months later. It was a total case of pimp my citizenship. It was the beginning of the still ongoing persection of Mr. Kiessling.
Cacau never played for Germany at any junior level either. Plus 1 third of all the goals he ever scored for Germany were against Malta lol so I know you hate him.

[MoFattal]

Raffael is an attacking midfielder, and mostly a secondary striker, a position which is already packed with some of the best players in the world right now. No need to dig much into this discussion

[Jorge]

No way. Cacau was born in 1981 and did not play for his first German team until 2000. Hardly learned his football in Germany. he got his citizenship in Feb 2009 and made his international debut 3 months later. It was a total case of pimp my citizenship. It was the beginning of the still ongoing persection of Mr. Kiessling.
Cacau never played for Germany at any junior level either. Plus 1 third of all the goals he ever scored for Germany were against Malta lol so I know you hate him.

At the time I discussed this issue with a Brazilian friend and at the end we agreed on one thing: we have to look not only at the receiving country (Germany) but also the issuing country (Brazil), is Cacau a Brazilian Footballer? Let’s see:

Cacau was actually unknown in Brazil when he put on the German jersey having played in Brazil for 2 seasons at age 16-17 for Atletico Nacional, a small semi-amateur club that plays only at local level in São Paulo, the very bottom of the Brazilian Football. He moved to Germany because of some personal connections to play for a tiny small amateur club that plays locally in Munich and some games around the Bavaria. This is the time when he caught the eye of a Nürnberg scout that put him on their reserve team in at age 18.

You decide, IMO Cacau’s case is different and although you may have an argument saying he isn’t German there is an even stronger argument supporting that he isn’t Brazilian footballer.

[scaPEPgoat]

Well everyone's case will be different from someone elses but I do agree it is not as blatant as Raffael would be. I did not realize he was unknown when he moved to Germany (although how well known was Raffael before he left Brazil. Not being rhetorical, I really have no idea) or that his Brazilian outfit was such a minnow (I mean I saw they were called Nacional so that at least sounds like they are at the national top-level, right?) but still I am sure he learned a few of his tricks growing up in Brazil. If you look at it by his age alone then it would be like if Max Meyer left for Arsenal this month and then 5 years later kitted up for the 3 lions. Nobody around here would say Max Meyer was an English player. Now if Holtby ever played for England (and they are so bad maybe he will one day) it would be a different case. But yeah, obviously there are different views on passport players and I respect your opinion. I think it is unfair personally. Not as bad when they are from Brazil because usually they would not be good enough to play for their homeland anyways. But even still, if players from all over the world are coming to play in the great Buli then it is stupid if after 5 years (or whatever it is) they can all poach a national team spot away from the German players. As Luis Figo said when Deco was added to Portuguese team in 2004:
"I don't think people would be happy in Spain if I became a Spanish national and played for the Spanish side."

"It's something that distorts team spirit and I don't agree with it."

"If you're born Chinese, well, you have to play for China.

"I have nothing against those who do that but it's superficial.

"It looks like you're trying to take advantage of something. That's my opinion and I'm not going to change it because he is in the team."

Although that was 10 years ago and nowadays some European countries would probably charge figo with a hate crime if he said that but oh well. The key of what he said for me is that it distorts team spirit. In sports it is common to hear expressions like "the team that wanted it more won" or "that team won because they showed more heart" Well, in my opinion, it is unlikely that a world cup win for germany means as much to a cacau or a raffael as it would mean to a kiessling or a Kevin Volland