FC Bayern Forum

nm462272 wrote:you have a good point, but it's also possible that Neuer insisted on taking the penalty himself.

I find that very unlikely. The only time he took a pen was when everyone else chickened out.

Come on at the end of the day the team showed heart and created chances. Schweini and Thiago had very good chances to score, but they were only chances all you can ask is the player to put it on frame. I mean Thiago's good but asking him to make a turning split second shot I don't begrudge him not putting it top right corner at 100 kpm.

Maaaaybe the team can practise penalties but at the end of the day the players go through so many skill exercises you expect the captain and another senior player at least not to slip. I dunno I give credit where credit is due maybe Bayern should have done better but Dortmund have been at the bad end of a lot of decisions, they finally got the better end of the 60/40 decision.

RedQueen wrote:@Mia san Bayern, you can rationalize this all you want, matter of fact is that by Pep's own words we don't practice penalties ahead of games that can go to penalties, because he doesn't want to give the players the feeling that they can't win in regular time. If you don't practice penalties, you lack the routine and you're more likely to miss when it counts. You're also more likely to chicken out and leave it to your goalkeeper to take one, who by his own words doesn't practice penalties, not only ahead of big games, but ever. I'm kinda surprised that apparently no one but me wonders why he, and not for example Schweinsteiger or whoever else was still on the pitch, stepped up and took the fourth.

Maybe Schweini was meant to be fifth. Probably could have rotated once we'd seen EVERYONE miss their penalties, so perhaps you are right. Don't think it would have mattered though.

Feeling really bad for Boateng, though. He wanted so badly to play in the final.

Unless Thiago and Müller were injured, Pep fucked this one up!

RedQueen wrote:

nm462272 wrote:you have a good point, but it's also possible that Neuer insisted on taking the penalty himself.

I find that very unlikely. The only time he took a pen was when everyone else chickened out.

I think he might've offered to take one if there wasn't any volunteers. And there probably wasn't as Müller, Lewandowski and Thiago were all out.
All the Neuer-haters are now having a field day, btw.

RedQueen wrote:@Mia san Bayern, you can rationalize this all you want, matter of fact is that by Pep's own words we don't practice penalties ahead of games that can go to penalties, because he doesn't want to give the players the feeling that they can't win in regular time. If you don't practice penalties, you lack the routine and you're more likely to miss when it counts. You're also more likely to chicken out and leave it to your goalkeeper to take one, who by his own words doesn't practice penalties, not only ahead of big games, but ever. I'm kinda surprised that apparently no one but me wonders why he, and not for example Schweinsteiger or whoever else was still on the pitch, stepped up and took the fourth.

Well tbh this is the first penalty shootout (out of 3) we have lost under Pep's reign and we've converted most of our penalties during games too . So it might be true what you've said but honestly losing 4 out of 4 penalties can't be just explained by that. I think Schweini didn't step up and took the fourth because he traditionally takes the fifth penalty. Or he might have chickened out like the others for the same reason as in the last penalty shooutout at the AA.

What's most important for the players is to learn from this match, get over it and always show the will to win during the game whatever may happen. If we do this and manage to play at the top of our level we have a chance against Barca because they're not impossible to beat despite having the best attack in the world. It's going to be very tough and possible additional injuries certainly won't help but Bayern must do everything in their powers to go through against Barca.

pyrasur wrote:Maybe Schweini was meant to be fifth. Probably could have rotated once we'd seen EVERYONE miss their penalties, so perhaps you are right. Don't think it would have mattered though.

It wouldn't have mattered for this game, but it matters a lot in regard to the mentality of the team if I'm right. I really, really thought this (chickening out of taking penalties in a shootout) was over. Then they're not where I thought they were.

I'm actually kinda glad Neuer missed too. Imagine the embarrassment if he had been the only one who scored.

This is very strange that you guys don't see anything wrong with Pep, the team played their usual passing game forever, even with 11 against 10. No sign of any urgency at all. Game turn out to be normal as previous games with one difference, no luck at all, but team like Bayern should not require any!
Well, maybe we all will be lucky to see finally Pep's plan B in the game with Barca.

MillaMjau wrote:I think he might've offered to take one if there wasn't any volunteers. And there probably wasn't as Müller, Lewandowski and Thiago were all out.

That's quite likely. Still there were 9 outfield players left, so leaving it to the goalkeeper, who says he never practices shooting penalties ever, should be the last of all possible options.

All the Neuer-haters are now having a field day, btw.

The Neuer haters have gone really quiet lately, given the recent performances of the so-called world best keepers De Gea and Courtois.

So how many chances to score did we have when it was 11v10? You are right though the team should have had more urgency. If only Lewy had gone MORE into that 50/50.

Korab wrote:This is very strange that you guys don't see anything wrong with Pep, the team played their usual passing game forever, even with 11 against 10. No sign of any urgency at all. Game turn out to be normal as previous games with one difference, no luck at all, but team like Bayern should not require any!
Well, maybe we all will be lucky to see finally Pep's plan B in the game with Barca.

And what's the problem with that? We completely outplayed Dortmund for at least 100 out of 120 minutes. It's been ages since a Bayern-Dortmund game was so one-sided in favour of Bayern. That's what makes the loss hurt.

Korab wrote:This is very strange that you guys don't see anything wrong with Pep, the team played their usual passing game forever, even with 11 against 10. No sign of any urgency at all. Game turn out to be normal as previous games with one difference, no luck at all, but team like Bayern should not require any!
Well, maybe we all will be lucky to see finally Pep's plan B in the game with Barca.

Besides maybe the Müller sub, Pep is the last person I'd blame for this game. We created enough chances today to score 2 or 3 more goals, but the players just failed to convert. Can't blame him for fatigue or injuries either.

Looking back, what a little **** Schmelzer is, walking past Lewandowski on the floor to congratulate Langerak for crushing him. At least there was one BVB player who had a mind to check on Lewy. I can't believe someone managed to calm Pep down from that one.

This is just plain stupidity. To play robben when he just got back from injury and u know theres barcelona in the semifinals and to sub in him with only 25 minutes left in the game, while ur leading 1-0. This coach just makes me wow...