FC Bayern Forum

We have partnered up with Voopl.co to bring you a means to rate players' performance after each Bayern match! Your forum account is all you need. Try it out here: bundesliga-f3/bayern-munich-vs-borussia-m-gladbach-t12686-45.html#p312906

Can't see tweet? Click here!

Oh seriously, zero replies? You've become an ungrateful bunch, y'know

I think you launched it at the wrong time & on a wrong day my friend;-)

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2

It's a brilliant new feature and maybe it can be the base for our player of the month thing?

via Tapatalk

That's a great new feature. Can we just have it pinned somewhere where we can always find it? Like the first/last page of the match thread, for example.

Best consideration I have is editing the first post in the match thread, which I already did on the gladbach thread

We want a coaches (Pep) rating as well if you could include that. See last live chat thread at the bottom

sterndessudens wrote:We want a coaches (Pep) rating as well if you could include that. See last live chat thread at the bottom

I'll suggest it.

Hi everyone,

First of all, thanks Mark for giving us a chance to introduce our idea.

We're a small team of developers from France, football fans, and the creators of Voopl.

We've imagined and built a website allowing people to vote for their favorite club's player's performance on each match.
This allows fans, and more precisely forums to have a unified voting system and get a better view of their team's individual and collective performances throughout the season: ratings for players, teams, matches, sorted by season and/or competition.

The goal is to have as many people as possible to participate, and weigh against media and journalists which almost only rely on goals and assists to evaluate players performances nowadays. Fan votes, even though they're not perfect, give a different vision of a match than these stats.
An algorithm has been put in place and will be perfected through time to ignore spammers as well as "weird" votes such as giving everyone either 1 or 10.

The first games already showed a difference between fan and journalist voting, the former being much less prone to overrating hyped strikers and underrating defenders.

The site is still in beta and votes are only allowed for a few teams, including Bayern. The aim of the platform being quality votes, people are only allowed to choose and vote for one team.

Here's our website: http://voopl.co

Please tell us what you think of the website, if you have any criticism to make or if there are features you wish to see added.

We hope you will engage to rate and say what you think about your team's performance.

Kind regards,
Mehdi and the Voopl Team.

Very interesting feature. I'll have a stab at using it after the Dortmund v Bayern match.

Soooo... The proper spelling is "Mehdi"?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Can anyone link me to any German media that provides ratings each game? A respected and not Marca like rating system if there's such a thing. Thanks.

MUTU, I can't see the results of the votes at the first page. It says "You need to be logged in to the forum to use Voopl. Please log in and reload the page." I can see the ratings in voopl site but not the forum specific. I'd like to take a look how our ratings compare to other sites like whoscored and squawka. Don't know any others since I didn't really pay attention to this before.

pyrasur wrote:Soooo... The proper spelling is "Mehdi"?

Usually, it's Mehdi yeah.

runaway wrote:Can anyone link me to any German media that provides ratings each game? A respected and not Marca like rating system if there's such a thing. Thanks.

I check Goal.com or L'Équipe, which is french, but the ratings are only available on the printed version.
I know Bild rates players but I think you need to buy the printed version too...

My bad the grades for the last game are here : http://www.bild.de/bundesliga/1-liga/sa ... .bild.html

Bottom of the page.

Yeah I've found Bild's player ratings. Not sure about the range. 6 is the worst to 1 is the best? Goal also got one but I don't trust anyone who frequents that site seriously hehe