itisrising wrote:I'd say Kompany is better than Hummels.
BayernLove wrote:Thiagoalcantara wrote:Feghouli signed for West Ham on a free transfer.
Really good transfer for them and a cheap alternative to Lacezette. West Ham is rising up the ranks and will probably end up top 6-8 next season at the minimun.
Sure hope so, West Ham is the only English team I like and Feghouli is looking like a solid transfer on a free.
itisrising wrote:FCBayernMunchen wrote:itisrising wrote:He wasn't very good for us and was homesick. Shame that we didn't sell him on for more but he may never have thrived if he was here. And Kompany would walk into your side if he was fit.
Maybe a couple of years ago but definitely not after the Hummels transfer.
I'd say Kompany is better than Hummels.
PunkCapitalist wrote:FCBayernMunchen wrote:He wasn't very good for us and was homesick. Shame that we didn't sell him on for more but he may never have thrived if he was here. And Kompany would walk into your side if he was fit.
Maybe a couple of years ago but definitely not after the Hummels transfer.
Thiagoalcantara wrote:AS a pure defender, Hummels is definitely not top 2.
As an overall player vs other cbs, he is highly regarded... Hummels to me is the german version of David Luiz and Pique. Very technical and very good going forward. However, both have mental lapses. However, Luiz is faster/quicker, while hummels is probably stronger. All would excel in possession based teams and would contribute quite a lot going forward.
It's weird how you germans criticize south american fullbacks for being too offensive, but not strong defensive, however, hummels essentially is a better offensive player than a pure defender.
MUTU wrote:Just because Hummels is strong in the air and able to score from headers during corner kicks doesn't mean he isn't defensively strong. For me, defensively, when on top of their game, Boateng and Hummels are the top two defenders in the world. Maybe I'm biased, but that's my opinion.
Thiagoalcantara wrote:This isn't 2012-13.
Kompany nor Hummels is a top 5 cb in the world.
prasun77 wrote:Thiagoalcantara wrote:This isn't 2012-13.
Kompany nor Hummels is a top 5 cb in the world.
Yes sure the top 5 are Pique,Luiz,Pepe,Mangala and Skrtel..
Thiagoalcantara wrote:SHHHH...
Maybe, we can name some indian players. WAIT.....
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests